The Holger’s Scale vs the IPS-Score
A Review of Percutaneous Implant Complication Scores for Audiologists
What is the Holger’s Scale?
The Holger’s Scale was created as a measure of the clinical status of soft tissue surrounding a titanium implant, such as the Ponto™ System. Its goal was to evaluate the frequency and magnitude of adverse reactions more effectively in this population in future research.1
How was it developed?
The foundation of the Holger’s Scale was a comprehensive study that examined 60 patients who received 67 abutments/implants. Patients were followed for periods ranging from three to 96 months. Over this period, only one implant was removed for reasons associated with skin complications.1Why is this relevant for audiologists?
The Holger’s Scale is a simple tool that clinicians can use to record any adverse skin reactions ranging from swelling and redness to skin overgrowth and implant removal. Additionally, this measure is often utilized in research regarding percutaneous implants.1Where do most patients lie on the Holger’s scale post-Ponto implantation?
Studies show that Ponto implant patients, when undergoing the MIPS or MONO procedures, typically have minimal skin-related complications as noted by a Holgers Score of ≤2.2,3 Remarkably, 97 percent of patients exhibit no or minor skin reactions post-operatively.Are there any limitations to the Holger’s Scale?
Kruyt et al. (2017) suggest several limitations to the Holger’s Scale despite its simplicity and usability.4 These include:- The scale can be used to indicate treatment, but these decisions are not standardized.
- The scale was designed to evaluate skin reactions three months post-operatively, and thus cannot evaluate complications in healing.
- The scale does not evaluate any pain reported by the patient.
- Skin height, in regards primarily to skin overgrowth, is not noted in the original Holger’s scale. Often, skin overgrowth can lead to abutment changes or revision surgery.
No matter which scale you utilize, Ponto implantation patients experience minimal complications post-operatively, and thus benefit from excellent skin outcomes, favorable aesthetic results, and fast recovery times with few complications.5,6
References
-
Holgers KM, Tjellstrom A, Bjursten LM, Erlandsson BE. Soft tissue reactions around percutaneous implants: a clinical study on skin-penetrating titanium implants used for bone-anchored auricular prostheses. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants. 1987 Winter;2(1):35-9. PMID: 3471713.
-
Holmes, S., Hamiter, M., Berry, C., & Mankekar, G. (2021). Tissue preservation techniques for bone-anchored hearing aid surgery. Otology & Neurotology, 42(7), 1044-1050.
-
Data on file at Oticon Medical, Clinical study BC108
-
Kruyt, I.J., Nelissen, R.C., Johansson, M.L., Mylanus, E.A.M. and Hol, M.K.S. (2017), The IPS-scale: A new soft tissue assessment scale for percutaneous and transcutaneous implants for bone conduction devices. Clin Otolaryngol, 42: 1410-1413. https://doi.org/10.1111/coa.12922
-
Oticon Medical Whitepaper – The MONO procedure
-
Lagerkvist H, Carvalho K, Holmberg M, Petersson U, Cremers C, Hultcrantz M. Ten years of experience with the Ponto bone-anchored hearing system—A systematic literature review. Clin Otolaryngol. 2020; 45: 667–680. https://doi.org/10.1111/coa.13556
Hilary McManus, AuD
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipiscing elit dolor